Bankruptcy And The Family Home
Can I Keep My House
With No Equity?
Bob and Sue’s home is presently valued at $700,000 and the mortgage owing to the bank is also $700,000 meaning that they have no equity in their house. So, what will actually happen to Bob and Sue’s house now that they are going to go bankrupt?

House Has $30k or More in Equity



House Is Owned By
One Partner?
In this case study Bob and Sue have been married for 15 years but their home is entirely in Sue’s name. Bob’s name is not on the title or on the mortgage but they have both resided in the property for the entire 15 years they have been together. Bob is needing to file for bankruptcy.
Surrendering the House to the Bank.
So, Bob and Sue decide to surrender their home to the bank. The very first thing we at Bankruptcy Experts Melbourne would do for them is get them to sign a legal document which is like a deed of release meaning they have voluntarily surrendered their house.


Selling the House to a Family Member Prior to Bankruptcy, Is It Legal?



A Question of Caveats
Bob and Sue have owned a property for many years, have worked really hard and have $200,000 equity in their home. Their house is valued at $700,000 and they currently have about $500,000 on their mortgage.
Bob is a builder and has really been struggling since he hurt his back. He owes $150,000 in unpaid accounts to a particular hardware store who have been very patient with Bob and are aware of his situation.



Names on House Titles



Big 5 Questions
– Is Going Bankrupt Right for me?
– Will I lose my job?
– How will my income be affected?
– Can I keep my house or car?
– Will I lose my business or can I still be self-employed?
If you are considering bankruptcy, being able to answer these questions is vital. Then you’ll know exactly what will happen to your business and assets should you choose to file for bankruptcy. Feel free to download our eBook for free and inform yourself today. Or, if your questions are more complex, call us directly on 1300 795 575.





Get your FREE copy of the Big 5
* We promise not to bombard you with emails and phone calls when you sign up for our free e-book. In fact, we promise to only call you once to see if we can help you further and that’s it.
When The House is in Your Partners Name and They Don’t Need to Go Bankrupt.


When the House Is In Your Name, You Need To Go Bankrupt And Your Partner Has Contributed To The House.
Bob owns a Melbourne home worth $700,000 he owes the bank $600,000 and as a result has $100,000 equity in the property. Bob now needs to go bankrupt and he’s very worried about losing his home when he applies for bankruptcy, especially considering his partner Sue has actually been contributing financially towards mortgage payments for the last five years.



Why Would You Go Bankrupt If You Had Equity In Your House?



Can I Sell My House To A Family Member Before I Go Bankrupt ?
Let us say Bob and Sue own a property worth $700,000 and they owe $650,000 on the mortgage. They desperately wish to hang on to the Melbourne property as it has some sentimental value and some practical implications as Sue’s grandmother lives in a granny flat out the back and their disabled daughter needs the wheelchair access set up at the property.
But I Have Mortgage Insurance?


What If My Partner Wants To Buy My Share of the Property When I go Bankrupt?
Bob and Sue need to know if there is any way once Bob declares bankruptcy that Sue can potentially buy out Bob’s interest in the property and retain their home. The answer is yes, possibly. When Bob goes bankrupt Sue can approach the bankruptcy trustee and offer to make a payment of $50,000 for Bob’s half of the equity in the property.



I Have Heard My Property Can Be Tied Up for Eight Years or More When I Go Bankrupt?



What If I Can Not Keep Paying the Mortgage Halfway Through My Bankruptcy ?
What If I Decide to Hand the House Back to the Bank When I Go Bankrupt, How Long Do I Have Before I Am Required to Leave?


Surely I Can Keep
The Family Home If I Go Bankrupt?
Unfortunately in lots of bankruptcy situations, as we have seen in these case studies, keeping your house is not an easy process. Many times it is just not possible. Keeping your home in bankruptcy is all about the money, it is not about the sentimental value, emotional value or your own specific circumstances it is an extremely cut and dry procedure.
What If My House Was Purchased With an Inheritance?
The question is, if Sue puts her inheritance money toward their property, is that money safe if Bob and Sue decide they need to apply for bankruptcy? In Victoria the answer to that question is no, it is not safe at all.


I Bought a House With Compensation Money, Is That Money Safe If I Go Bankrupt?


Will I Still Have to Pay Rates, Insurance and Body Corp If I Go Bankrupt?
On the day they declare bankruptcy Bob and Sue will no longer continue to be the owners of their house. The bankruptcy trustee will generally remove Bob and Sue’s names from the title and put the trustee’s name in their place, then the house is simply handed back to the bank. Even if Bob and Sue had outstanding rates of $8,000 owing at the time of bankruptcy they will now not have to pay them and any overdue household debts will not affect them handing the house back to the bank.
Can I Keep My House with No Equity?
Let us say Bob and Sue own a property worth $700,000 and they owe $650,000 on the mortgage. They desperately wish to hang on to the Melbourne property as it has some sentimental value and some practical implications as Sue’s grandmother lives in a granny flat out the back and their disabled daughter needs the wheelchair access set up at the property.
The question is can they sell the property to Granny to keep the property so that they can remain on there as tenants after bankruptcy? In Victoria the short answer to this question is yes, if done in the correct way.
Our couple, Bob and Sue, decide to cover their mortgage commitment and at the same time look after Granny offering her a bargain, selling her the house for $650,000. They understand full well that it is actually worth $700,000 and that they are selling their home to Sue’s grandmother for less than market rate. In this situation the sale might end up being a huge problem for Bob and Sue. They have essentially avoided paying their creditors $50,000 of equity that the creditors should have received if the property was sold at a reasonable market rate. To safeguard themselves against this mistake Bob and Sue should have had a registered real estate valuer assess their property to figure out the true market value, prior to selling to Sue’s grandmother at that established amount.
So, as you can see in this scenario the issue was not that they sold the house to a member of the family, the problem was that they sold it to a family member at less than market value.
In this situation another trap that Bob and Sue could easily fall into is trying to transfer the title of the house prior to bankruptcy. Let us say that Bob and Sue desperately want to keep their house, however, Sue’s grandmother is on a pension, has no savings and no capacity to borrow any money. As Granny is not able to purchase the property from them Bob and Sue decide to transfer the ownership or the title to Sue’s grandmother before they go bankrupt hoping that this will protect them from losing their home. This scenario is considered the same as if Bob and Sue gifted the property to Granny, it does not work merely changing whose name is on the title in bankruptcy, it is about following the money. In bankruptcy simply changing the ownership title on a house or property will not do anything to safeguard it from being sold as an asset.
If it looks like you might be heading towards bankruptcy and you have questions about your home, give Bankruptcy Experts Melbourne a call on 1300 795 575 for all the answers.
Will I Still Have to Pay Rates, Insurance and Body Corp If I Go Bankrupt?
On the day they declare bankruptcy Bob and Sue will no longer continue to be the owners of their house. The bankruptcy trustee will generally remove Bob and Sue’s names from the title and put the trustee’s name in their place, then the house is simply handed back to the bank. Even if Bob and Sue had outstanding rates of $8,000 owing at the time of bankruptcy they will now not have to pay them and any overdue household debts will not affect them handing the house back to the bank.
Should Bob and Sue decide to keep the property after declaring bankruptcy that is a completely different matter. If they stay on in their home they will still be responsible for any body corporate fees, rates, insurances, and any other expenses related to home ownership.
Should Bob and Sue decide to keep the property after going bankrupt that is a totally different matter. If they stay on in their house they will still be liable for any body corporate fees, rates, insurances, and any other costs associated with home ownership.
If you are not too sure exactly where you stand with your rates or other household bills when declaring bankruptcy, feel free to call us here at Bankruptcy Experts Melbourne on 1300 795 575 for well-informed and appropriate guidance.
I Bought a House With Compensation Money, Is That Money Safe If I Go Bankrupt?
Before we explore this any further, when it comes to bankruptcy any compensation payments in either a lump sum or as weekly payments are very complicated. Our advice in this circumstance is to ensure you get some proper advice before you apply for bankruptcy. Do not just take what we say here as gospel because there are a lot of variables in this very tricky situation.
After his accident at work Bob got $200,000 in compensation, he put the full $200,000 towards his home which is worth $700,000, he and Sue now only owe the bank $500,000 Bob and Sue have decided to declare bankruptcy and there is effectively $200,000 equity in the property.
In Victoria compensation money acquired as a result of an accident is generally considered safe and protected when you declare bankruptcy. In this circumstance Bob’s compensation money that he put towards the house is safe despite the fact that he has gone bankrupt. Bob and Sue can continue to keep the $200,000 which has become equity in their home, whether they choose to sell the house or stay residing in it. The money Bob has as a result of his compensation payments is safe. This does not always apply with compensation money, in some cases if you receive compensation due, for instance, to an illness it can be quite complicated.
If you are looking at declaring bankruptcy in VIC, before you do anything give us a call here at Bankruptcy Experts Melbourne on 1300 795 575for expert assistance and guidance.
What If My House Was Purchased With an Inheritance?
The question is, if Sue puts her inheritance money toward their property, is that money safe if Bob and Sue decide they need to apply for bankruptcy? In Victoria the answer to that question is no, it is not safe at all. Inheritances and inheritance money received prior to bankruptcy are still looked at as assets and as such are still exposed to the bankruptcy trustee. The trustee can take any asset of yours as a part of your bankruptcy estate, so do not assume that any inheritance or inheritance funds are safe when you file for bankruptcy, they are not.
To learn more about inheritance moneys and how they, and other assets, are impacted by bankruptcy, call Bankruptcy Experts Melbourne on 1300 795 575.
Selling the House to a Family Member Prior to Bankruptcy, Is It Legal?
Let us say that Bob and Sue’s home is worth $700,000 and they owe the bank $600,000. They decide to sell the property to Bob’s uncle Joe for $600,000, believing that will clear their mortgage debt and Uncle Joe gets a bargain. The problem here is the bankruptcy trustee will ask what the value of the property was when they sold it. Bob and Sue will tell them it was worth $700,000 and the trustee will tell them that they should have sold it to Uncle Joe for the full $700,000. In this circumstance the bankruptcy trustee will instruct Uncle Joe to pay the bankruptcy estate the $100,000 discount that he believed he had saved buying Bob and Sue’s property. To safeguard themselves from the possibility of selling their house too cheaply before they went bankrupt, Bob and Sue really should have had an independent valuation done on the property before it was sold. They should also have made sure that the transaction was done properly using a solicitor or conveyancer to help them with the sale. If you are looking at selling your house to a member of the family prior to bankruptcy don’t attempt anything tricky, keep it a strictly commercial transaction the same as if you were selling to a complete stranger.
These are just the basics of selling a house to a member of the family prior to going bankrupt. This process is generally much more complex, so if you would like to learn more feel free to call us here at Bankruptcy Experts Melbourne on 1300 795 575.
Surely We Can Keep Our Family Home When I Go Bankrupt?
Unfortunately in lots of bankruptcy situations, as we have seen in these case studies, keeping your house is not an easy process. Many times it is just not possible. Keeping your home in bankruptcy is all about the money, it is not about the sentimental value, emotional value or your own specific circumstances it is an extremely cut and dry procedure. When you are bankrupt if there is equity in your property the equity needs to be realised so creditors get paid some or all of what you owe them. That is how bankruptcy operates in Victoria, no matter what your circumstances, if you have a home that you have equity in then it is under threat when you declare bankruptcy.
If you need some advice about your family house or anything to do with bankruptcy feel free to call us here at Bankruptcy Experts Melbourne on 1300 795 575. We will walk you through all your bankruptcy options and what you can do with your house.
What If I Decide to Hand the House Back to the Bank When I Go Bankrupt, How Long Do I Have Before I Am Required to Leave?
The good news is, it is not as fast as you may assume. Every situation is different depending upon the banks, the bankruptcy trustee and the individuals but basically Bob and Sue do not need to panic, they will not need to be out the next week or anything ridiculous like that. Leaving your home is normally quite a reasonable process and sometimes the bank may even ask you to remain in the property to help them sell it.
In this type of situation, if Bob and Sue are up to date on their mortgage they will usually have about two or three months to vacate. If Bob and Sue were really way behind on their mortgage repayments then the bank will more than likely want them out sooner rather than later. Either way, once they go bankrupt Bob and Sue will have time to find and move into a new place to live.
If you are concerned that you are going to lose your home because of bankruptcy call us at Bankruptcy Experts Melbourne on 1300 795 575 and we can guide you through your options.
What If I Can Not Keep Paying the Mortgage Halfway Through My Bankruptcy?
It truly is that easy, remember in bankruptcy Bob and Sue are both already bankrupt so simply handing the house back even if the bank makes a loss when they sell is not Bob or Sue’s problem. This is the one get out of jail free card you get in life if you can’t afford to pay your mortgage.
There is much more involved in this situation of course so if would like more detail on what you might need to do in this bankruptcy scenario, give Bankruptcy Experts Melbourne a call on 1300 795 575.
I Have Heard My Property Can Be Tied Up for Eight Years or More When I Go Bankrupt?
If you retain a property, it is standard to have it revalued when you reach the end of your bankruptcy. In Bob and Sue’s case their home was revalued and it had actually increased in value from $700,000 to $780,000. In order to have the property released back to them they would be required to pay the trustee $80,000 which is the equity that the house has actually increased by over the three years of bankruptcy. The trustee will now continue to keep ownership of the property till Bob and Sue have done one of two things. One, they can choose to sell the property as it is now worth more than when they initially went bankrupt. Two, Bob and Sue have the option to locate $80,000, pay it to the trustee and once it is paid have the house back. However, finding $80,000 is difficult, especially when you have been bankrupt, it could take Bob and Sue two or three years to come up with $80,000. In this circumstance the trustee would continue to keep the house in the trustee’s name past the three year period of bankruptcy, this enables Bob and Sue to pay off the $80,000 gain in equity and so keep their home.
In Victoria there are a number of other reasons why a trustee might continue to keep the house locked into the bankruptcy process beyond the three years but essentially it all comes down to money like most things in bankruptcy you just have to follow the money.
Believe it or not it is very easy to have your house tied up in the bankruptcy process for a number of years well after your release from bankruptcy. If you have a home in VIC and want advice on how you might be able to keep your property in bankruptcy, call us at Bankruptcy Experts Melbourne on 1300 795 575. We can help you work through what your alternatives are and how you can best prevent any complications.
But I Have Mortgage Insurance?
Fast forward a few years and Bob and Sue are in financial difficulty and need to apply for bankruptcy, what is even worse is that the Melbourne house is now worth $150,000 less than what their mortgage is. Bob and Sue are not really concerned about the mortgage due to the fact that they had paid for mortgage insurance coverage. The sad fact is the mortgage insurance is not there to help safeguard Bob and Sue from any shortfall if the house sells for less than the mortgage, it is actually there to safeguard the bank’s interests. In this circumstance, the bank will hand any financial shortfall to the mortgage insurers if the house sells for less than the value of the mortgage. The mortgage insurance company will then pursue Bob and Sue for the shortfall.
The reason Bob and Sue were required to pay mortgage insurance way-back when they got the mortgage was because they could only come up with a 5% deposit which exposes the bank to higher risk, meaning the mortgage insurance provider will require a greater premium. The banks pass on this additional premium cost to the purchaser, which is what Bob and Sue were paying for. In a nutshell, mortgage insurance is not there for you it is there for the bank.
At Bankruptcy Experts Melbourne we can help you navigate through the minefield of bankruptcy, call us on 1300 795 575 to take the first step.
Why Would You Go Bankrupt If You Had Equity in Your House?
Even though they have a reasonable amount of equity in their home Bob and Sue feel they will need to go bankrupt as they cannot draw on any of that equity to pay their other debts. Bob until recently had been the primary income earner in their relationship but, unfortunately, he has lost his job. Since Bob is now unemployed and Sue does not have a very high income their ability to make repayments has been severely impacted. In this situation the bank will not agree to let them borrow against the equity they have in their house.
Another hurdle Bob and Sue have encountered has been though they have been struggling to repay debts to a variety of different creditors, there have been some defaults and judgements on their credit report. Once their credit rating dropped it become more difficult to borrow money to cover their various debts. This unfortunate situation can became a vicious circle which can be tough to get out of without contemplating bankruptcy.
If Bob and Sue only had $18,000 worth of debt and $100,000 equity in the house it is very likely that their application for bankruptcy would be rejected simply because they have a lot of equity in their home.
If you own a home in Victoria and are thinking about bankruptcy you can access some totally free advice by contacting us here at Bankruptcy Experts Melbourne on 1300 795 575 and we can walk you through your options.
When the House is in Your Name, You Need to go Bankrupt and Your Partner has Contributed to the House.
Bob owns a Melbourne home worth $700,000 he owes the bank $600,000 and as a result has $100,000 equity in the property. Bob now needs to go bankrupt and he’s very worried about losing his home when he applies for bankruptcy, especially considering his partner Sue has actually been contributing financially towards mortgage payments for the last five years. In Victoria the technical term for this circumstance is called the doctrine of exoneration. What does it mean? Simply put, it means that a person who has financially contributed to a property despite the fact that they are not on the title or mortgage has some claim against the equity in the property should the person who owns the house file for bankruptcy.
In this first case, Sue had actually sold a property before she got together with Bob and she contributed $30,000 towards the deposit of a house for them to reside in. At the time Sue was not working so the property title and mortgage was only put in Bob’s name. Sadly things didn’t go well for Bob and he had to apply for bankruptcy. Even though it is only Bob’s name on the title and the mortgage of their house, Sue has a genuine claim to get her $30,000 back. Sue can make a claim to the trustee for her $30,000 to be returned if the property needs to be sold. If Bob and Sue want to hang onto the property Sue’s claim to the $30,000 of equity means Bob now only has $70,000 of equity and not $100,000, potentially making keeping their house a lot more feasible.
In this next scenario Sue can again have a claim against some of the equity in Bob’s home should he go bankrupt. If Sue has actually paid 50% of the mortgage over the past five years she will be entitled to a portion of any equity in the property. Even if the title and mortgage for the house is only in Bob’s name.
Should Bob declare bankruptcy, potentially Sue is able to claim some of the equity in Bob’s home if they have combined their financial lives. If over the five years they have lived together they have shared equally all the household expenses and costs then Sue is entitled to some of the equity in Bob’s house, regardless of not being on the title. This can even apply if Sue has not specifically made payments towards the mortgage.
Another manner in which Sue might claim some equitable interest in the property is because her name is on the mortgage. When Bob and Sue bought the house they put the title in Bob’s name only as Sue had a very risky profession at the time and was concerned about legal claims against her. However, in order to secure the mortgage for the house both Bob and Sue were listed on the home mortgage as they required both their incomes to contribute to buying the property. Even though she is not on the title as an owner of the house because she is on the mortgage she is entitled to a proportion of the equity should Bob file as bankrupt.
Sue received a redundancy payout a couple of years ago and contributed $40,000 towards some renovations, new carpet, paint and new bathrooms in the house she lived in with Bob. Although Bob owned the house and had always made all the mortgage payments when he was required to go bankrupt Sue was able to claim $40,000 equity in the house when it needed to be sold.
As you can see from these case studies, in VIC, there are a number of ways in which a partner can have a claim to equity in a bankrupt partner’s property. Should you be facing bankruptcy and not know where you or your partner stand Bankruptcy Experts Melbourne can provide you the answers and guide you through the procedure. Call us on 1300 795 575 to find out how we can help.
When the House is in Your Partners Name, and They Don’t Need to Go Bankrupt.
A common myth in Victoria is that if the title of the home you reside in is in your partner’s name then the house will be safe if you declare bankruptcy, however, it is not that simple. This is a situation where it is really about following the money or establishing what money has contributed to the property and whose money that is.
Let us say for instance that before Bob and Sue purchased their property they now reside in, Bob owned a little apartment in the Melbourne city centre. Bob made a tidy sum of $50,000 when he sold his apartment and he added that towards a deposit for the house he lives in now with Sue. Although the new property is clearly Sue’s with only her name on the title and the mortgage he has actually still contributed $50,000. What this will mean is that if Bob goes bankrupt the trustee will ask if he has actually contributed any money towards the property at any point and as he has in this case the trustee might require that to be paid back toward his debts.
Another situation could be that for the last 5 years Bob and Sue have resided in this property Bob has been paying half of the mortgage each month. Although the property is only in Sue’s name, contributing to the mortgage means that Bob has assisted in the ownership of the house. By making regular or lump sum payments to a home loan Bob can be seen to be contributing toward the asset and unintentionally the house also becomes in part Bob’s asset, despite the fact that he is not on the title.
It can get even more complicated than that, let us say that our couple Bob and Sue have been residing in Sue’s house for the last five years and have contributed equally to the household bills. They both share equally in paying the mortgage, rates, purchasing food and sharing the expense of household items that need to be purchased. In this case the trustee will more than likely say that because they have shared their financial lives together for the last five years a portion of the equity in Sue’s property is in fact Bob’s.
A few years ago the whole back patio area of the house that is in Sue’s name was rotted out and needed to be changed. Bob had some money from a redundancy payout from his job so he decided to not only pay for the patio area renovations but to also do some of the work himself. By doing this the bankruptcy trustee can again consider Bob to now have some amount of equity in Sue’s home.
Another case where Bob might be in difficulty is if his name is on the mortgage because the bank would not lend Sue the money unless they both signed due to her capability to make repayments. Despite Bob not putting any money towards the deposit, his name is on the mortgage because he earns money that will help contribute to making the repayments. In this circumstance it is quite easy for the bankruptcy trustee to see that the house is in both Bob and Sue’s names and both have actually contributed toward the property and therefore towards any equity in the property. It could be that as much as 50% of the equity in the house is classified as Bob’s.
If you are in a circumstance where you reside in a property owned by your partner and have approaching bankruptcy worries give us a call for helpful guidance. These case studies are by no means the entire story, there are a lot of other situations that need to be considered and getting the appropriate information is essential. By giving Bankruptcy Experts Melbourne a call here on 1300 795 575 we can walk you through the potential pitfalls of what might occur if you declare bankruptcy.
Names on House Titles
The question is, will this action safeguard their property in any way when Sue files for bankruptcy? In short, the answer is no; they cannot merely just transfer the name of the title and after that magically have a new owner appear. The main reason why this is not possible is that Sue needs to disclose any gifts or transfers of property when she declares bankruptcy. When the trustee sees this transfer they will just say that Sue has done this purely to defeat creditors or to not pay her bills when she declared bankruptcy. This strategy will not work in Victoria and it really is just a waste of time.
We described in a previous case study, a couple who had been residing together in a property for a great length of time entering bankruptcy with only one partner’s name on the house title. As shown in that scenario, even if your name is not on the title you may well be liable for some of the equity in that property. So, names on titles do have a purpose when dealing with bankruptcy but they are definitely not a guarantee of security for your asset. Bankruptcy is really simply a matter of following the money, it is about equity asset value and who has actually paid what over what amount of time. These sort of numbers and these sorts of calculations are more the philosophy behind how assets are determined when you go bankrupt instead of just names on titles or mortgages.
If you wish to know more about titles of property and how bankruptcy will impact it, feel free to call us here at Bankruptcy Experts Melbourne on 1300 795 575 and we will walk you through it. Do not assume that you have it all covered this is a very complex area of bankruptcy law and you can easily get it wrong.
A Question of Caveats.
Bob is a builder in VIC and has really been struggling due to the fact that he injured his back. He owes $150,000 in unpaid accounts to a particular hardware outlet who have actually been very patient with Bob and understand his situation. However, they are simply not able to wait anymore, so to make certain that they get their payment for the account they have placed a caveat over Bob and Sue’s property.
Generally, as a mortgage holder you will be informed from your creditor that a caveat has been placed on your property and you may also be contacted by the land titles office. What this means for Bob and Sue now is if they sell their property for $700,000 and they still owe the bank $500,000 the caveat for $150,000 will now come into effect. Effectively the maths from the sale of their house will be, they pay the bank $500,000 mortgage, then pay the hardware outlet the $150,000 caveat leaving Bob and Sue with $50,000.
What happens to a caveat when you go bankrupt? Well the reality is not too much, although Bob and Sue are not required to pay the hardware store as a result of declaring bankruptcy this does not automatically get rid of the caveat. So, what needs to happen is Bob and Sue need to go through the process of the bankruptcy and at the end of the 3 years the debt for the hardware store will be removed and they will no longer owe the hardware store the $150,000. They can then ask for the hardware outlet to remove the caveat as this does not automatically happen. If they won’t Bob and Sue may need to get some legal advice to force them to do so.
This is, of course, a very simple description of how caveats work in Victoria, there is a lot more to it than we have briefly outlined. This example is not legal advice, it is merely just an example of how caveats work. Please do not hesitate to seek your own independent legal advice about caveats if you have one on one of your properties because it is a very important issue and there are frequently complications.
There are various situations and scenarios that can be considered in the case of a caveat, if you want to know more about them and how they can affect bankruptcy feel free to call us here at Bankruptcy Experts Melbourne at any time on 1300 795 575.
Selling the House to a Family Member Prior to Bankruptcy, Is It Legal?
Let us say that Bob and Sue’s home is worth $700,000 and they owe the bank $600,000. They decide to sell the property to Bob’s uncle Joe for $600,000, believing that will clear their mortgage debt and Uncle Joe gets a bargain. The problem here is the bankruptcy trustee will ask what the value of the property was when they sold it. Bob and Sue will tell them it was worth $700,000 and the trustee will tell them that they should have sold it to Uncle Joe for the full $700,000. In this circumstance the bankruptcy trustee will instruct Uncle Joe to pay the bankruptcy estate the $100,000 discount that he believed he had saved buying Bob and Sue’s property. To safeguard themselves from the possibility of selling their house too cheaply before they went bankrupt, Bob and Sue really should have had an independent valuation done on the property before it was sold. They should also have made sure that the transaction was done properly using a solicitor or conveyancer to help them with the sale. If you are looking at selling your house to a member of the family prior to bankruptcy don’t attempt anything tricky, keep it a strictly commercial transaction the same as if you were selling to a complete stranger.
These are just the basics of selling a house to a member of the family prior to going bankrupt. This process is generally much more complex, so if you would like to learn more feel free to call us here at Bankruptcy Experts Melbourne on 1300 795 575.
House Has $30k Or More In Equity.
So, in Victoria, what will happen to their home when they file for bankruptcy? In this case study we can consider the equity as anything above $30,000 so this would be the same scenario as if their equity was $30,000, $100,000, $300,000 or $1,000,000 it doesn’t make any difference the principle is the same.
Bob and Sue have decided they desperately wish to keep their home despite the fact that it has some equity in it. When Bob and Sue initially applied for bankruptcy they owed $300,000 in debt to banks, credit cards, tax and a whole range of different creditors. For Bob and Sue to keep their house in bankruptcy there are two options. The first option is to just pay the trustee at the start of bankruptcy a lump sum of $30,000 to make up for the shortfall between the house value and the house mortgage. To do this they would need to get the $30,000 from a friend, relative or someone else because as a bankrupt they do not have any money. Paying the trustee $30,000 at the beginning of the bankruptcy will settle and satisfy the creditors that they have gotten the value of the equity out of the property and everybody is happy.
The second option if they don’t have access to $30,000, they can as bankrupts enter into a payment plan with the trustee, paying off the $30,000 over the 3 year duration of their bankruptcy. At the end of their bankruptcy providing of course the house has actually not increased in value and their equity is still not more than that $30,000 the creditors will be satisfied and they can retain their house.
This payment arrangement does not automatically happen if you have some equity in your property and you file for bankruptcy. Bankruptcy in Victoria is a complicated complex procedure that you need to be really careful entering in to, particularly if you want to keep a family home in which you have some equity.
If you want to keep your house in bankruptcy you can get sound professional guidance from us here at Bankruptcy Experts Melbourne. Call us on 1300 795 575and we can walk you through your options.
House is Owned by One Partner.
In this case study Bob and Sue have been married for 15 years but their home is entirely in Sue’s name. Bob’s name is not on the title or on the mortgage but they have both resided in the property for the entire 15 years they have been together. Bob is needing to file for bankruptcy.
In this particular circumstance it is most likely that the trustee will view some of the equity in the property as Bob’s although he’s not on the title or mortgage. The reason for this is simply because they have both contributed to household bills and have been living together financially for the last 15 years. Although not necessarily documented on paper Bob has actually contributed to the maintenance of the house while living together in it.
So, Bob and Sue have lived together in Sue’s house for 15 years and the property is worth $700,000. The bank is still owed $500,000 so Sue has $200,000 equity in the property. In this situation the trustee could well say that of the $200,000 equity half of that or $100,000 is actually Bob’s because they have both lived there for 15 years. This is the worst case scenario. If it can be clearly established that Sue has contributed solely to the mortgage and household expenses and Bob has not, it demonstrates a real imbalance. In this case it can be established that the equity in the house is not half and half despite the fact that Bob has lived there for 15 years he potentially only has 10% or 20% of calculated equity. This is not locked in stone. This is something that needs to be worked out and is determined at the time of bankruptcy.
If, for instance, Bob had just moved in with Sue six months earlier and she had owned the house for many years prior to their relationship and him moving in, this would be treated very differently. The simple reason being that there is very little history of them both living in the same property. In this scenario it is quite likely that Sue will be able to keep full equity in the house and there will be no problems at all.
Please don’t automatically presume at any point that because your partner’s name is on the title and mortgage that your home is safe, that is not always the case. In VIC establishing equity in a property needs to be proven rather than through simply taking your word for it. Things like mortgage statements, bank statements, payslips and other paperwork may be required.
Here at Bankruptcy Experts Melbourne we have the experience to walk you through establishing your property equity, call us on 1300 795 575 so we can assist you through the process.
Surrendering the House to the Bank.
So, Bob and Sue decide to surrender their home to the bank. The very first thing we at Bankruptcy Experts Melbourne would do for them is get them to sign a legal document which is like a deed of release meaning they have voluntarily surrendered their house. This means the bank does not need to pursue legal action to have them removed from the house. Bob and Sue would then vacate the property, although in some cases the bank may ask the residents to stay on and live in the property to help them in selling it.
The reality is the bank that lent Bob and Sue the money for the house are not worried whether they declare bankruptcy or not. The bank will always get their money for the property because they have the loan secured against the property or another similar asset and can potentially sell it at any point to get the money. In Bob and Sue’s case their house is sold and it ends up that it sells for $150,000 less than their mortgage, the bank will then ask Bob and Sue to pay the $150,000 shortfall. If Bob and Sue are bankrupt the $150,000 then simply goes onto their bankruptcy documentation, this does not have to happen prior to declaring bankruptcy or at the beginning of bankruptcy in fact it can happen at any time throughout the 3 years. Sometimes, properties might take a year or two to sell so this process will just happen as a part of the bankruptcy process. If the real estate market is really bad and the property does not sell then it is still not Bob and Sue’s problem, even after the three years of bankruptcy the problem is still the banks and they will take care of the asset or the house whenever they can.
In Victoria when you surrender your house to the bank there is a false assumption with some mortgage holders that as they have actually paid for mortgage insurance this will somehow secure them from any shortfall if the bank sells the house. This is absolutely not the case, in fact mortgage insurance is not there for you as the mortgage holder it is there for the bank to secure its mortgage. If you fail to pay your mortgage the bank will just hand over to the mortgage insurer and the bank will get its money for the house. When the house is sold the mortgage insurance company will then come after you for any shortfall. The only time you can have your mortgage wiped out is once you are bankrupt and the house is sold making the debt unsecured.
The minute Bob and Sue surrender their property to the bank or to the bankruptcy trustee whether they are in bankruptcy or not they will no longer be responsible for the rates or the maintenance or the upkeep or even the insurances on that property. They are basically no longer the owners of the property and can simply walk away.
If you want to apply for bankruptcy in VIC and are worried about what will happen if you walk away from your house, do not hesitate to call us here at Bankruptcy Experts Melbourne on 1300 795 575 and we will take you through your options.
Can I Sell My House to a Family Member Before I Go Bankrupt?
This is a question that, on the surface of it, sounds terribly risky, however it is not if you know what you are doing and things are done in an appropriate commercial manner.
Let us say Bob and Sue own a property worth $700,000 and they owe $650,000 on the mortgage. They desperately want to hang on to the property as it has some sentimental value and some practical implications as Sue’s grandmother lives in a granny flat out the back and their disabled daughter requires the wheelchair access installed at the property.
Our couple, Bob and Sue, decide to cover their mortgage commitment and at the same time look after Granny giving her a good deal, selling her the house for $650,000. They know full well that it is actually worth $700,000 and that they are selling their house to Sue’s grandmother for less than market rate. In this situation the sale could become a huge problem for Bob and Sue. They have essentially avoided paying their creditors $50,000 of equity that the creditors should have received if the property was sold at a fair market rate. To protect themselves against this mistake Bob and Sue should have had a registered real estate valuer assess their property to determine the true market value, before selling to Sue’s grandmother at that established amount.
So, as you can see in this scenario the problem was not that they sold the house to a family member, the problem was that they sold it to a family member at less than market value.
In this situation another trap that Bob and Sue could easily fall into is trying to transfer the title of the house prior to bankruptcy. Let us say that Bob and Sue desperately want to keep their home, however, Sue’s grandmother is on a pension, has no savings and no capacity to borrow any money. As Granny is unable to buy the property from them Bob and Sue decide to transfer the ownership or the title to Sue’s grandmother before they go bankrupt hoping that this will protect them from losing their house. This situation is considered the same as if Bob and Sue gifted the property to Granny, it does not work simply changing whose name is on the title in bankruptcy, it is about following the money. In bankruptcy just changing the ownership title on a house or property will do nothing to protect it from being sold as an asset.
If it looks like you might be heading towards bankruptcy and you have questions about your house, give Bankruptcy Experts a call on 1300 795 575 for all the answers.